I'm looking forward to seeing all of you tomorrow in our zoom meeting.
It's heavy stuff we're dealing with Wednesday and Friday. Well, it's heavy for me, at least. Imagine twenty or thirty years from now, and you're facing a group of 20-somethings who have absolutely no reference for what it was like to live through the COVID-19 pandemic. It's fictional for them. They get that it was a big deal, but they probably don't know it in the same way that you all know it.
That's something like what AIDS is. When I was your age, AIDS was The Scary Thing, a plague that was as far as we knew 100% deadly. You got it, and it was a death sentence. And, somewhat similarly to the coronavirus, you could have it for a while and not have any symptoms, spreading it unknowingly to others. If you were sexually active, an intravenous drug user, or--early on--someone who received blood transfusions, every cough, sneeze, blemish, fever, or illness made you wonder, is this it? Unlike, COVID-19, AIDS also had an aura of shame around it. If you had it, many people in the 80s and 90s thought, you kinda deserved it. (One of the first times I heard about AIDS on the news in the 80s was as "Gay Cancer" or GRID--Gay-Related Immunodeficiency.)
Watching the documentary (Théo is doing the extra report on it) How to Survive a Plague was difficult for me, though I highly recommend the movie ($4 rental on Amazon Prime). The shame and fear and anger and hope and pride and desperation of the people featured brings back lots of memories, and I say this as someone who came in late to AIDS awareness. (Also--I was shocked to see a young Dr. Anthony Fauci as such a prominent figure in the story. I had forgotten that. He's been around for a long time.)
AIDS is still with us. Baton Rouge remains at or near the top of the nation in terms of new HIV infections. Access to the lifesaving drugs that make AIDS manageable is starkly limited by income here and abroad.
For Wednesday, though, we're diving into the initial, intensely scary phase of AIDS in the US. We weren't sure what this disease was, how it was spread, whether a treatment/vaccine was possible. There was a ton of silence and shame about having it or being at risk for it. And, unlike coronavirus, no one in power seemed to give a damn.
From a theatrical point of view, consider how the two plays we're reading, As Is and The Normal Heart, each take a different stylistic approach to this crisis. As Is uses a bit of distancing/theatricalization. Normal Heart opts for realism/naturalism. Consider what each stylistic choice enables the play to do.
For another taste of this period in the AIDS crisis, see this poem, "How to Watch Your Brother Die."
For more on the state of AIDS treatment, prevention, and research today, see this video:
For another dramatic portrayal of the early AIDS crisis, see the 1993 movie And the Band Played On, based on a memoir by Randy Schilts. It's available free on YouTube:
Here's Kendall's prompt for post 4:
###
After reading The Normal Heart and As Is it is clear that they are very similar in many ways. They both show the realities of the AIDS crisis for the gay men at risk, they showcase a couple where one man has AIDS, they even both show a brother that is unable to properly be there for his gay brother in the crisis. The main difference that I found between the two plays was the level of abstraction. The Normal Heart is painfully realistic showing just how many people these men knew that were dying and how scary it was that no one would listen to them. The dialogue is realistic and all of the characters are played by one person. On the other hand, As Is is much more abstract with a chorus-like group of 6 people playing many parts, multiple scenes happening at once, and, what I thought was the most compelling choice, the "cliffhanger" ending by not letting the audience know if Rich did in fact die. Why do you think each playwright chose to write his play as he did? What is the purpose for the abstraction or the realism? What effect does As Is have that The Normal Heart doesn't have an vice versa?
So here's a
fun lil video of a Butoh performance in Japan. Butoh, which means
"dance of darkness", is a form of abstract dance that came about in
Japan after World War 2 as a means of coming to terms with the
atrocities their country had experienced. We have talked a little bit
about how abstraction can help us deal with emotional things sometimes
better than realism can, which explains why so much abstract art came
about after each of the World Wars as well as other traumatic events in
history.
###
Here's Rain's prompt/artifact:
Artifact:
https://time.com/5803273/hoarding-toilet-paper/
This is an article from Time that delves into why people have been hoarding toilet paper, of all things, during a world pandemic. It goes into the comfort of always having it around and even the primal instincts humans have adapted since they were babies. This may provide more insight on the question I asked and help relate the play to today’s events.
###
From Hannah:
These AIDS plays brought me back to a good old Script Analysis
favorite of mine, Marburg. In that play, a 17 year old boy seeks sex
with a HIV positive man. Buck hopes to be infected on the premise that
infection is inevitable, so he may as well have unprotected, or, what he
considers to be "real" sex without fear and uncertainty.
Marburg takes place
in a later time than Normal Heart. Much more is understood about AIDS
and HIV in Marburg, but to even consider this option of wanting HIV is
difficult to digest after reading the devastating and largely autobiographical Normal
Heart.
I read As Is after Normal Heart. In As Is,
Rich has a fit of frustration with everyone’s fear of being near him/his
condition and (sarcastically-but maybe not) yells about wanting to infect the
whole city. This is followed by scenes in a bar, where a version of him fantasizes
about having risky sexy with "clones". This scene is jarring after
reading about Larry Kramer’s efforts during the epidemic. This scene abstractly
addresses the idea of loss that the gay community felt not only literally, but
in their sense of community. Even the scene in Marburg where the boy
says that he “wants to feel human again,” touches on this in a different way
than Normal Heart was able to through its autobiographical realism.
Can we compare those who took no preventative measures against
AIDS to those who are not taking preventative measures against COVID-19? Many
say that it was a right for those with AIDS to have consensual sex with negative
partners. Transitively, could one argue that a group of friends hanging out together
exclusively during COVID is their right? Consider the likeness of the viruses-contagious,
life threatening, and the differences in national response-complete dismissal
vs. quarantine.
Artifact: a dream that my friend had LAST NIGHT.
"I was a
nurse who purposely sought out coronavirus so that I could catch it and become
immune. I wanted to be able help more people and take the weight off my fellow
staff members. I don't even know if that's how this virus works. I'll look it up.
..... hm. You can build immunity, at least for
a short amount of time. Wow, I was doing the lord's work. It could have mutated
and I would have been responsible for ending the human race, but what good intentions!"
###
Finally, here's your relaxing musical moment of beauty, from the incomparable Brandi Carlile:
Dr. Fletcher loves ya.
No comments:
Post a Comment